KKC Theory Wiki

Denna's WMF Letter Hides a Coded Message in Its Out-of-Place Capital Letters

fringe mechanism · popularity 78 · 1 source thread

The oddly capitalised words in Denna's letter may form a hidden cipher, possibly naming her secret patron.

About: Denna

Also involves: Kvothe, The Wise Man's Fear, Imre, The Adem

The theory§

In The Wise Man's Fear, Denna leaves Kvothe a letter explaining her sudden departure from Imre, and the letter is studded with words capitalized out of place, a hallmark of concealed writing. Reading the stray capitals in sequence yields the string 'Yoosshcmwffkml,' which this theory proposes hides secret content, possibly the identity of Denna's patron or an instruction Denna cannot state plainly. The capitalized words run You, Opportunity, Occasional, Sporadic, Small Kingdoms, Screaming, Horses, Cussing, Mercenary, Furtherance, Means, Letter, and several readings note these track the very events Kvothe goes on to experience after receiving it. Competing explanations hold that the capitals reflect an archaic noun-capitalizing convention rather than a code, or that any true cipher resolves only against a specific printed page layout, as a Japanese-translation analysis suggested. The letter also fits Denna's established interest in Yllish knot-magic and naming that 'makes you think something is true,' raising the possibility it is enchanted rather than merely encoded.

Evidence§

  • It has some totally out of place capitalised letters, which is CLASSIC code writing. I knew I was onto something as soon as I saw it, she had to be hiding information.
    OP's core claim: out-of-place capitals signal a hidden code. — u/JackofScarlets
  • I'm about to reveal the name of Denna's sponsor, hiding in her out-of-place capital letters: Yoosshcmwffkml.
    OP's claimed result: stray capitals spell a string naming her patron. — u/JackofScarlets
  • The code isn't the letters, it's the words that are capitalised.
    Refinement: read whole capitalized words, not just their initials. — u/Au_Norak
  • You, Opportunity, Occasional, Sporadic, (Small, Kingdoms), Screaming, Horses, Cussing, Mercenary, Furtherance, Means, Letter.
    Lists the actual capitalized words forming the proposed message. — u/Oxyfool
  • Yoo ssh cm wff kml You should come with ____ camel?
    Decoding attempt: parses string into a plain-language instruction. — u/LNinefingers
  • if you look at only the 'important' words (words capitalized that shouldn't be), it sounds like she's saying there is a rare opportunity where she is that she can't outright tell him about.
    Reads capitals as a covert message Denna cannot state plainly. — u/chainsawx72
  • the capitalized words in the letter are directing Kvothe's journey to Felurian. They are all symbolic and chronological to what happens throughout the book.
    Refines theory: capitals track the very events Kvothe later experiences. — u/Ragnanicci
  • she talked about magic that makes you think something is true. Maybe it is the same in this letter as when she made knots in her hair that said "lovely".
    Alternative: letter is Yllish knot-magic enchantment, not a cipher. — u/rubberbandshooter13
  • it may not even be code, but it's possibly a very archaic way of writing where anything that might count as a noun is capitalized, which is still a practice extant in some languages.
    CounterCounter: capitals may be an archaic noun-capitalizing convention, not code. — u/Achna
  • If for the EN version logic is the same - it may be related not to letters, but to spans or something similar that only makes sense in a printed version.
    CounterCounter: any true cipher may depend on printed page layout, per Japanese analysis. — u/Detnoi

Book refs: WMF, WMF ch 43

Tier reasoning§

fringe confirmed: cipher yields gibberish, capitalisation likely stylistic

Contributors§

Source threads§