KKC Theory Wiki

Kvothe's Parting Mischief in Severen May Have Seeded a Vintish War

fringe timeline · popularity 55 · 1 source thread

By selling court gossip and dumping noble signet rings in a brothel, Kvothe may have destabilised Severen's court.

About: Kvothe, Severen, Vintas

Also involves: Maer Lerand Alveron, Ambrose Jakis, Bredon

The theory§

On departing Severen, Kvothe performs two final acts of spite against the Vintish nobility that may have left lasting damage to the Maer's court. First, he sells the stack of slanderous letters the nobles had sent to his rooms to a disreputable dockside publisher, bargaining up to six reels and six pennies for every printed copy sold, then burns the contract and washes his hands twice, ensuring the court's gossip becomes a printed book of rumours. Second, he empties a sackful of nobles' signet rings into a bowl at a dockside brothel, where the women squabble over the silver ones. The theory holds that in Vintas's rigidly stratified court the silver rings carry social meaning, so commoners wearing them could provoke scandal or violence, planting seeds of the war Kvothe is rumoured to have caused. Against this, a ring proves nothing on its own, since rings are routinely lost, pawned, or sold for coin, and only become meaningful at court when their bearer's possession can be authenticated by the sender.

Evidence§

  • He offered me four reels for the lot of them, plus the promise of ten pennies for every volume of the book he sold after they were printed. I bargained him up to six reels and six pennies per copy and we shook hands. I left his shop, burned the contract, and washed my hands twice.
    OP's first act: Kvothe sells the nobles' slanderous letters to a publisher to be printed. — u/JustAGuy026
  • So I poured the sackful of rings into a bowl and left them on the bar. Soon the ladies were trying them on and arguing over who would get the silver ones.
    OP's second act: Kvothe dumps the nobles' signet rings at a brothel for the women. — u/JustAGuy026
  • the silver rings implied that they were of equal status. Given the divide between the common people and nobility in Vintas, is it wrong to assume this would have a major effect on the court in Severen?
    OP's core claim: silver rings signal equal status, so commoners wearing them destabilises the court. — u/JustAGuy026
  • I don't remember if it's ever said what war Kvothe caused, but if it is a Vintish war … then is it possible that Kvothe had sown some of the seeds for that all the way back here?
    OP links these acts to the war Kvothe is rumoured to have caused. — u/JustAGuy026
  • the notion they were not anonymous would prove violent for the gossips.
    Comment refines: if the gossips' names were attached, publication turns violent. — u/luckydrunk_7
  • The prostitutes would talk … and Meluan would delight in making sure everyone knew what Kvothe had done.
    Comment supports fallout: the rings will be traced and Meluan will publicise Kvothe's act. — u/khazroar
  • Having a ring doesn't establish anything by itself. What makes them meaningful in court is that your possession of the ring can be authenticated by other people.. In particular by the sender.
    CounterCounter: a ring proves nothing alone; rings are lost, stolen or pawned routinely. — u/Zhorangi
  • It's all just rumour and gossip, the same as flows around court anyway … I don't see much significant fallout really.
    CounterCounter: the published gossip is ordinary court rumour with little real impact. — u/khazroar

Book refs: WMF

Tier reasoning§

tier confirmed: events are canon but the war-seeding link is speculative

Contributors§

Source threads§