Cinder
“The white-haired Chandrian who killed Kvothe's troupe”
also known as Fe, Ferula, Ferule, Lord Haliax's lieutenant, White-haired
Appearance§
Cinder is a creature of winter's pale, cold and sharp and white, with chalk-white skin and hair the color of frost. His eyes are black and irisless like a goat's, reflecting neither firelight nor the light of the setting sun. He carries an unnatural chill, and frost spreads in his presence as his Chandrian sign. He wields a distinctive sword, pale and elegant, that cuts the air with a brittle sound and likewise absorbs light, reflecting neither fire nor sun; it reminds Kvothe of the quiet that settles on the coldest days of winter, when it hurts to breathe and everything is still. He appears as an imposing, graceful figure in chain mail.
Description§
Cinder is one of the Chandrian, a pale, white-haired figure who serves under Lord Haliax and answers to the true name Ferule, rendered Ferula in the telling of the troupe's massacre. He led the band of Chandrian that slaughtered Kvothe's troupe and killed his parents, questioning the hidden child about the songs his parents had been singing and toying with him cruelly before Haliax rebuked him for his little cruelties and addressed him by name. Kvothe remembers his face clearly and counts him chief among the Chandrian against whom his vengeance is aimed. Years later Cinder leads a band of bandits in the Eld who raid the Maer Alveron's tax collectors; Kvothe and his companions ambush and destroy the band, and Cinder, shot through the leg with an arrow, escapes. The Cthaeh later confirms the bandit leader was Cinder and reveals an old grievance between them. Under the alias Master Ash, Cinder courts Denna and acts as her patron. His Chandrian sign is the cold: fire turns blue and gutters in his presence, water grows still, and frost spreads where he stands.
Relationships§
- Killed Parents Kvothe — killed Kvothe's parents and toyed cruelly with the hidden child; Kvothe's chief target of vengeance
- Member Of The Chandrian — one of the Chandrian who slaughtered Kvothe's troupe
- Patron Of Denna — under the alias Master Ash, Cinder courts Denna and acts as her patron
- Serves Haliax — serves under Lord Haliax, who rebukes him and names him a tool in his hand
- Exposed By The Cthaeh — the Cthaeh confirms the bandit leader was Cinder and reveals an old grievance
- Wronged Laurian — the Cthaeh reveals Cinder did terrible things to Kvothe's mother
- Raided Maer Lerand Alveron — leads bandits in the Eld who raid the Maer Alveron's tax collectors
- Alias Master Ash — under the alias Master Ash he courts Denna
- Killed Arliden — led the Chandrian who killed Kvothe's father and questioned the child about the songs
- Operated In The Eld — leads a band of bandits in the Eld, ambushed by Kvothe and companions
Established facts§
- Cinder is one of the Chandrian and serves under Lord Haliax.
- His true name is Ferule, rendered Ferula in the account of the troupe's massacre, and Haliax addresses him by it.
- Cinder killed Kvothe's parents and led the Chandrian who slaughtered his troupe, toying cruelly with the hidden child.
- He questioned Kvothe about the songs his parents had been singing, the troupe having sung of Lanre and the Chandrian.
- Haliax rebuked Cinder for his little cruelties and named him a tool in his hand.
- Cinder wields a pale, elegant sword that cuts the air with a brittle sound and reflects neither firelight nor the setting sun.
- Cinder has chalk-white skin, frost-white hair, and black, irisless eyes like a goat's that reflect no light.
- His Chandrian sign is the cold: fire turns blue and gutters near him, water grows still, and frost spreads where he stands.
- Cinder later leads a band of bandits in the Eld who raid the Maer Alveron's tax collectors.
- During the ambush in the Eld, Cinder is shot through the leg with an arrow and pulls it free without apparent harm.
- Cinder pauses and holds perfectly still as if listening during the attack, having heard Marten's prayer in Tehlu's name, just as he did at the troupe's killing.
- Cinder escapes the encounter in the Eld while his bandits are killed.
- The Cthaeh, who speaks only truth, confirms to Kvothe that the bandit leader was Cinder.
- The Cthaeh reveals that Cinder once did it a wrong turn, establishing an old grievance, and that Cinder did terrible things to Kvothe's mother.
- Under the alias Master Ash, Cinder courts Denna and acts as her patron.
- Haliax claims to keep Cinder safe from the Sithe, who hunt those who treat with the Cthaeh.
- Among the Adem, Cinder is named in song as 'Ferule, chill and dark of eye.'
- Nina's recreation of the Mauthen vase depicts Cinder as a black-eyed, white-haired man standing before a bare tree on a circle of water amid drifts of snow.
- Kvothe deliberately avoids using real names in his retelling, taking care not to speak Cinder's.
- Kvothe counts Cinder chief among the Chandrian against whom his vengeance is aimed.
Theories§
- plausible Cinder's Name 'Ferule' Encodes Iron, Bondage, and a Link to Denna's Patron pop 664
- plausible Denna's Mysterious Patron Is One of the Chandrian, Likely Cinder pop 503
- plausible Cinder's Bandits Were Targeting the Lackless Box, Not Tax Money pop 410
- plausible Cinder, Not Bredon, Is Denna's Mysterious Patron Master Ash pop 371
- plausible Folly, the Sword Behind the Bar, Is Cinder's Own Blade pop 344
- fringe It Was the Angels Who Called Down the Lightning, Not Kvothe pop 247
- fringe Bredon Is Master Ash, the King Is Cinder, and Kvothe Must Re-Seal Iax pop 220
- plausible Hearing Cinder's True Name Awakened Kvothe's Sleeping Mind pop 198
- fringe Cinder Is a Homunculus Shaped to Be Haliax's Tool pop 194
- fringe Cinder Is Already Dead, Killed by Kvothe Before the Frame Story pop 163
- fringe Cinder Used the Eld Bandit Raids to Lure Kvothe Into Freeing the Cthaeh pop 161
- plausible Cinder Is Master Ash, Denna's Mysterious Patron pop 158
- well-supported Kvothe's Knack for Names Points to Master Ash Being Cinder pop 156
- plausible Master Elm, Not Master Ash: Kvothe's Naming Knack Found the Truth He Then Misexplained pop 147
- fringe Kvothe Becomes the Silent Fire, the New Seventh Chandrian pop 121
- fringe Cinder Is Not Master Ash: 'Cinder' Names What Remains of Kvothe pop 118
- fringe Folly Is Cinder's Sword and Adem Swords Are Made by Shaping pop 117
- fringe Cinder's Deep Name Is Stercus, and 'Ferule' Really Means Iron pop 117
- fringe The King Kvothe Kills Is Cinder Possessing King Roderic Calanthis pop 117
- fringe Bredon Is Cinder, Embezzling His Own Northern Taxes From the Maer pop 114
- plausible Cinder Dies in Book Three Because Saying His Name No Longer Matters pop 92
- fringe Cinder Wants to Die and Steers Kvothe Toward Killing Him pop 88
- plausible Bredon Is Simply Bredon, Not Cinder or a Chandrian pop 88
- fringe Cinder Is the Wind Kvothe Actually Called on Ambrose pop 86
- fringe The Cthaeh Is a Black Wyrm Running a Fae Narcotic Trade pop 83
- fringe Cinder Fled Because Tehlu's Angels Answered Marten's Prayer pop 78
- fringe Kvothe Killed Cinder, Not the Poet King, in That Vintish Street pop 77
- fringe The Cthaeh's 'Stops to Buy a Drink' Line Foreshadows Cinder Entering the Inn pop 75
- plausible Bredon Isn't Cinder, But If a Chandrian He Could Be Haliax pop 72
- plausible The Cthaeh's Word 'Again' Hints Kvothe Will Meet Cinder One Last Time pop 70
- fringe Bast Mirrors Both the Cthaeh and Cinder in the Narrow Road Excerpt pop 70
- fringe A Full Doors of Stone Prediction: Cinder, Denna's Betrayal, and the Moon pop 68
- plausible Cinder's Cold Sign May Have Triggered the Fishery Bone-Tar Fire pop 68
- fringe Cinder, as Master Ash, Secretly Works Against the Chandrian pop 62
- fringe Cinder's Name and the Pain in His Voice Hint at a Buried Sithe or Amyr Past pop 62
- fringe Cinder Did the Cthaeh a 'Bad Turn' by Using the Breaking Way Against It pop 58
- fringe The Cthaeh Is Encanis and Cinder Is a Fallen, Transformed Tehlu pop 58
- plausible Cinder Was Disguised as Master Ash During the Fishery Fire pop 58
- fringe Kvothe Became the Seventh Chandrian and Changed His Name to Escape pop 57
- fringe Bredon, Cinder, and Denna's Patron Are All One Person pop 54
Appears in theories§
- plausible Kvothe Is Baiting the Chandrian to the Waystone, a Trap Built to Defeat Them pop 904
- plausible The Chandrian Are the Good Guys and the Amyr the Real Villains pop 761
- plausible Each Chandrian Betrayed a Specific City and the Riddles Tell Us How pop 633
- plausible Master Ash Is Baron Greyfallow, the Patron Behind Both Dangerous Songs pop 515
- plausible An Amyr, Not the Chandrian, Massacred Kvothe's Troupe pop 452
- fringe Seven Hidden Figures in Kvothe's Life Mirror and Counter the Chandrian pop 421
- fringe Denna Is a Chandrian: She Is Pale Alenta, Not Merely Their Pawn pop 397
- plausible Denna Has Deliberately Visited Each of the Seven Cities of the Ergen Empire pop 392
- plausible Denna's Patron Had Her Craft a Song to Rename Haliax pop 348
- fringe The Cthaeh Is Selitos, Bound by His Own Blood-Oath to the Tree pop 328
- fringe Kvothe's Folly Was Killing Haliax, Not Cinder pop 317
- plausible Denna's Backstory Mirrors Kvothe's, Her Family Slain by the Amyr pop 266
- plausible Denna's Patron Master Ash Has Not Yet Been Introduced pop 265
- plausible The Chandrian Warning Song Encodes Escape Instructions to the Fae pop 257
- plausible Kvothe's Life Mirrors Lanre's, Implying He Is on the Path to Becoming Haliax pop 257
Top contributors§
People on r/KingkillerChronicle who built the theories above.
- u/SomeGuyNamedJohn12 — 1 theory · 374 pts · corroborated
- u/AdonisChrist — 1 theory · 214 pts · corroborated
- u/smoothie_25 — 1 theory · 182 pts · corroborated
- u/Kit-Carson — 5 theories · 155 pts · clarified/countered/extended
- u/seregsarn — 1 theory · 153 pts · extended
- u/Isplayingcalvinball — 1 theory · 142 pts · extended
- u/PewterSavant — 1 theory · 138 pts · countered
- u/OldHolly — 2 theories · 116 pts · extended
- u/JesseJamesGames449 — 2 theories · 98 pts · corroborated/countered
- u/stepho14012 — 1 theory · 98 pts · extended
- u/TySwindel — 1 theory · 94 pts · corroborated
- u/fZAqSD — 1 theory · 94 pts · clarified